Uncategorized


School Discipline in Connecticut: Questioning Suspended Education

Though we know removing students from the classroom is harmful, exclusionary discipline continues to be used in schools across Connecticut. Research has shown that students who are suspended, expelled, or arrested are more likely to experience academic failure, drop out of school, and become involved in the juvenile justice system, feeding the school-to-prison pipeline. To help state leaders disrupt this pipeline, we analyze exclusionary discipline data to identify the factors affecting a student’s likelihood of entry to the system, and recommend interventions to disrupt their entry.

In past publications, we have raised concerns about the overuse and misuse of exclusionary discipline in public schools across the state:

  • “Arresting Development: Student Arrests in Connecticut” (2013). We analyzed school-based arrest data from 2007 to 2011 and showed that although the overall number of arrests had declined across the state, a significant portion of those arrests were avoidable—that is, students were arrested for non-criminal behaviors that could likely have been addressed in the classroom. While arrest rates were higher for students of color, students in poorer school districts, and students with disabilities, we observed significant variation in arrest rates across schools and districts with similar student populations, which suggested school policies and practices may impact rates of arrests.
  • “Keeping Kids in Class: School Discipline in Connecticut, 2008-2013” (2015). In our analysis of suspension, expulsion, and school-based arrest data from 2008 to 2013 we showed that as rates of exclusionary discipline use declined, schools continued to suspend, expel, and arrest students of color, students from poorer districts, and students with disabilities at rates disproportionate to their representation in the population of students enrolled in CT public schools. Additionally, in 2013, nearly 1 in 10 school-based arrests were for non-criminal violations of school policy (like profanity, insubordination, or dress code transgressions).

In our new series, School Discipline in Connecticut: Questioning Suspended Education, we take a deeper dive into school discipline data, closely examining which students bear the brunt of this overuse of discipline and identifying opportunities for intervention. Our past research shows that low-income students, students of color, and students with special education needs are disproportionately impacted by the overuse and misuse of exclusionary discipline. In this series, we study additional factors that may influence school discipline rates, including school type, degree of racial segregation, and intersecting student identities.

The first brief in this series, “Struggling with School Transitions,” highlights the potential relationship between school transitions and school discipline. Comparing rates of exclusionary discipline by grade level to enrollment data suggests that school transitions (e.g., from elementary to middle school or middle to high school) may be a point of stress for Connecticut’s students. School discipline rates spike in the sixth and ninth grades, grades in which the majority of the state’s students are starting at new schools. If student suspensions rise sharply in the sixth and ninth grades, and suspensions are associated with further exclusionary discipline, then the behavioral challenges of changing schools may inadvertently function to establish harmful patterns of removing students from the classroom, contributing to further problems down the line.

In upcoming briefs we will highlight factors including gender, race, disability status, English language proficiency, and racial segregation in schools and how these factors affect the type, severity and duration of discipline used. This series seeks to better identify the factors that influence the overuse and misuse of exclusionary discipline in schools. By developing targeted interventions to address these factors, the state can more effectively disrupt existing entry points in the school-to-prison pipeline, and improve school climate for all of its students.

Governor’s Proposal Puts Low-Income Families at Risk for Losing Health Coverage

This post was first published at the CT Mirror's CT Viewpoints website.

Connecticut has every reason to be proud of its long-term commitment to ensuring access to care for low-income children and families through the HUSKY program (Medicaid and Children’s Health Insurance Program).  We have one of the lowest rates of uninsured residents in the nation, thanks in large part to the State’s Medicaid program.  Long before enactment of the Affordable Care Act in 2010, Connecticut invested in the health of its children and their parents by aligning income eligibility for everyone in a family.  This policy was based on knowing that when whole families are insured, children’s access to care improves and parents stay healthy for work and family responsibilities.  Just last month, Connecticut’s  Governor Malloy, along with Connecticut’s budget director and state Medicaid administrators, extolled the quality improvements and cost savings realized through innovative changes to the HUSKY program.

Some of this progress will be undone if the Connecticut General Assembly goes along with the Governor’s April budget proposal to reduce income eligibility for almost 10,000 low-income parents. For example, in 2016 the income limit for a family of four would be lowered from $37,665 (155 percent of the federal poverty level (FPL) to $33,534 (138% FPL).   Because of federal Medicaid rules, the estimated savings associated with reducing coverage is just $900,000 in state fiscal year 2017.  This cutback in parent coverage follows a very significant change in eligibility just last year (from 201% FPL to 155% FPL), the full effects of which will not occur until this summer when up to 20,000 parents may lose HUSKY coverage.  Taken altogether, this proposal means almost 30,000 low-income parents could lose affordable health coverage over the course of this year and next. 

State officials have emphasized that affordable health care coverage is available for these parents through the health insurance marketplace, Access Health CT. However, even with federal subsidies for premiums and limits on out-of-pocket costs, coverage in a qualified health plan can be very costly for low-income families. For example, a family with two parents and two children earning $48,843 could be billed as much as $13,676 (28 percent of household income) for their health coverage.   In addition, dental health insurance for adults is a separate purchase, without premium subsidies and with significant out-of-pocket costs for limited coverage.

We now know what can happen when coverage is cut for low-income parents:  Last year, most parents were eligible for a one-year extension, putting off until July 31, 2016, the risk that they will lose coverage altogether.  Among those who actually lost coverage last summer (645 parents),  just one in four enrolled in a qualified health plan through Access Health CT, including some who experienced gaps in coverage.  Three of every four parents who were cut from HUSKY A last year are not currently enrolled through Access Health CT and may be uninsured. 

Missing from the data collected last year is whether eligible children were cut off inadvertently from the HUSKY program when their parents lost coverage, as happened in Maine and Wisconsin.  

Experience in other states suggests that the effect of the rollback of Medicaid eligibility can be reduced in part with policies that address the financial burden for families forced to pay for their own coverage.  For example, Connecticut could use state subsidies to help reduce the overall costs of marketplace coverage.  To date, we have not heard discussion of these or other proposals to mitigate the effect of this cutback on Connecticut’s families. 

Cutting income eligibility for parents—once again and before the full effects of last year’s cut are evident—is a huge step backward in Connecticut’s long-standing commitment to covering children and parents in low-income families. 
 

Ambitious Investments Will Boost Economy and Reduce Inequality

Annual Cost Chart

Last week, the Economic Policy Institute (EPI) released a report describing the high costs of child care in all 50 states, and the benefits of public investment in early childhood care and education. The authors of ‘It’s Time For An Ambitious National Investment in America’s Children’ propose an expansion of subsidies (known in Connecticut as Care 4 Kids) to allow parents access to affordable high quality child care, investments in high quality early education, and funding for before-and-after childbirth home visits – all of which will benefit children, families and the economy.

In their report, EPI finds that high quality child care is simply out of reach of many low- and middle income families. For example, in Connecticut, the annual cost for infant care is 6th highest in the nation at $13,880. This breaks down to $1,157 per month and is 37 percent more than in-state tuition at a four-year public college. Families with more than one child (an infant and a 4-year-old) would have to spend 29% of their income on childcare ($25,382 annually).

Annual Cost in Connecticut

Annual Cost Chart

Source: Economic Policy Institute: The Cost of Child Care in the United States

For too many families, the rising cost of childcare is prohibitive – particularly at a time of stagnating incomes. A full time minimum wage worker earning $19,968 annually would have to spend close to 70 percent of her annual income to afford high quality infant care for one child. Child care workers – low-wage workers themselves, earning on average just $21,840 yearly—would have to spent 63.6 percent of their annual earnings to put their own baby in infant care. Even for Connecticut families earning the median family income of $86,981, the cost of infant care amounts to 16 percent of household earnings, exceeding the recommendations of the US Department of Health and Human Services that child care costs should account for 10 percent or less of a family’s budget.

Expanding access to affordable care through subsidies and tax credits – such as the child and dependent care tax credit (CDCTC) – has enormous potential to improve the economic security of Connecticut families and the state’s economy. Among the findings:

  • Capping child care expenses at 10 percent of income would save the average Connecticut family with an infant $5,182 annually (it would save those with an infant and 4-year old $16,684 annually).
  • Decreasing child care costs by 1 percent would increase labor force participation by 0.2 percent, meaning more parents would be able to go back to work. The authors calculate that Connecticut’s gross state product (GSP) would increase by 1.2 percent or more than $3 billion annually.
  • Professionalization of the child care workforce would improve the economic well-being of providers and their families. Child care workers are disproportionately women and workers of color, meaning that higher wages among child care workers would help to close Connecticut’s gender-based wage-gap and vast racial pay gaps. By attracting and retaining a trained workforce, professionalization would in turn improve the quality of care.

Unfortunately, Connecticut, in response to structural budget challenges, is cutting investments in child care subsidy programs at a time when families can ill afford it; child poverty is at a record-high, low-wage work is replacing middle- to high-income work, and fewer families are being served by Care 4 Kids. The benefits to families and the state economy cannot be clearer. EPI is calling for an ambitious national investment in early childhood care and education, and we need the same here in Connecticut.

 

Building Connecticut’s Future

Public Infrastructure Has Been Neglected

As Connecticut’s slow recovery from the Great Recession enters its seventh year, it’s time to invest in rebuilding our long-neglected public infrastructure – a strategy that capitalizes on current low interest rates and will push long-term economic growth and lift wages.

A new report by the Center on Budget Policy and Priorities makes clear that America’s public infrastructure is being neglected. The American Society of Civil Engineers’ (ASCE) latest report card graded America’s public infrastructure at a “D+.” Bringing roads, bridges, water treatment facilities, and other infrastructure up to a state of “good repair” by 2020 will require $3.6 trillion of investment.
 

Public Infrastructure Has Been Neglected

Part of the problem is that we invest far less in public infrastructure than in the past, which could be related to the state’s lackluster growth. Federal spending as a percent of GDP on infrastructure has fallen by half over the past 35 years. State and local governments in all but five states cut infrastructure spending as a share of their economies from 2002 to 2013, the most recent year for which statistics are available.

Connecticut’s spending has followed this national trend over the past decade. Since 2010, however, only seven states, including Connecticut, have increased infrastructure spending as a share of the economy (a 0.12 percentage point increase).  Yet, Connecticut’s 2013 spending on infrastructure (1.49 percent of gross state product) remains less than it was in 2002 (1.70 percent in 2002). Connecticut’s spending also trails both the national average and several nearby states.

One reason this is a good time to recommit to public infrastructure investment is that states and localities can take advantage of unusually inexpensive borrowing. Nationally, interest payments on debt averaged just four percent of current spending in 2013, the lowest level since the Census began tracking this in 1977. This is driven in part by historically low interest rates, which are expected to continue.

State/Local Infrastructure Spending

Infrastructure investments can improve state economies – now and in the future. In the short term, infrastructure investments support employment – such as construction jobs – which are still below prerecession levels. For example, studies of the economic impact of infrastructure spending as part of the 2009 Recovery Act have found that a dollar of federal infrastructure spending has led to anywhere from $1 to $2.50 in additional GDP. Those effects would likely be somewhat less pronounced today, since we are no longer in the depths of a recession, but they would nonetheless be significant, since the state remains well below pre-recession employment.

Targeted infrastructure investments are also crucial in addressing inequality. Poorer areas often have worse infrastructure. Nationally, in areas where three-quarters or more of students are eligible for free and reduced lunch, a full 60 percent of schools are in need of repair. Low-income neighborhoods also often have a higher share of potentially-poisonous lead pipes. In most cases, such disparities are best addressed at the state level, since the municipalities themselves are usually poorer.  The CBPP report cites property tax systems in particular as contributing to municipal infrastructure gaps, an issue that could be alleviated through property tax reform in Connecticut.

The good news is that Connecticut is already re-prioritizing and starting to address its critical infrastructure, such as the “Let’s Go CT!” plan to provide a new rail connection between New Haven and Hartford, expansion of bus systems, highway improvements, and municipal transport infrastructure. Municipalities have also taken the lead. New Haven, for instance, is nearing the end of the largest per capita investment in its education infrastructure in the state.

Looking ahead, Connecticut can make further investments in areas of need. To best determine where infrastructure spending should be focused and how much should be spent, policymakers should consider several key questions: Where are the infrastructure assets most in need of repair in terms of geographies and disadvantaged socio-economic and racial groups? How can the state best finance its future capital investments?

By focusing the conversation on these questions, Connecticut leaders may find themselves one step closer to a path out of the state’s disappointing economic growth and towards a period of newfound dynamism.

Community Schools: Seizing the Opportunity

Community schools improve outcomes of the most vulnerable children and families and are a key reform strategy in the New Haven and Hartford schools, according to a new brief from Connecticut Voices for Children. Many other districts are also implementing pieces of the community school model, but in light of the major budget deficits and shrinking education funding, we see an opportunity to refocus reform efforts on leveraging existing community assets to produce better outcomes for children and families. The brief provides a status update on Connecticut community schools and outlines key policy recommendations.

Community schools involve a partnership between the neighborhood school and community organizations to reduce the opportunity gap, strengthen children and families, and increase learning. Mayors of big cities like New York, Cincinnati, and Philadelphia have pushed to increase the number of community schools as a key strategy to increase academic achievement among their most high-need students. Legislators in several states are also leading efforts to promote community schools as a key educational reform strategy. For example, the Connecticut General Assembly demonstrated its commitment to the community school model in 2013 with the passage of “An Act Concerning Community Schools.”

Community schools share four common features: 1) extended learning; 2) in-school mental and physical health services; 3) family engagement; and 4) family support and connection to social services. Several large-scale evaluations of national community school models show beneficial effects, improving student learning, and strengthening families and communities. Evaluations of Connecticut community school models in Hartford and New Haven also demonstrate positive outcomes for students, parents, and communities.

Implementation of community school models is not without challenges. Primary challenges include the need for better coordination of services, the commitment of state and district leadership, and the complications bridging school and community cultures. Although there is a perception that community schools are expensive to implement, community schools are cost-effective because they build on existing services at the local level. No new community school has been created since the 2013 legislation, but components of community schools exist in nearly every Alliance district. Nonetheless, greater coordination of services is necessary.

Our review indicates that the components of community school models can improve outcomes for children and families in under-resourced schools. We recommend that school and district leaders consider the following:

  • Maintain state funding that supports community schools, including grants to Alliance districts and funding for Family Resource Centers. The budget climate is dire, and preservation of funding for existing supports for vulnerable children and their families is of the utmost importance.
  • Provide supports for conducting a needs assessment at the school and district level, especially in an Alliance district, to determine which resources are currently available in the school and in the community.
  • Identify a full-time coordinator at the school and/or district level who conducts a needs assessment, establishes partnerships between school and community partners, and coordinates the key components of community schools.

Ensuring success in school and in life increasingly depends on establishing crucial links between what happens in and outside of the classroom. Community schools are one educational model that bridges schools and communities to create more equitable educational experiences for all children. The legislation on community schools already exists, and the resources in many districts are in place to make this happen. These resources remain at serious risk in the current fiscal climate, and it is unlikely that the state of education funding will improve in the near future. School and municipal leaders, state legislators and families must seize this opportunity to make connections, linking the classroom to the community, to prepare all of our state’s children, especially the most vulnerable, for academic and economic success and active participation in civic life.

Read the brief.

Connecticut Voices for Children celebrates the release of “Home: Voices of Connecticut’s Foster Youth”

This post originally appeared on the First Focus blog.

On January 11, 2016, Connecticut Voices for Children celebrated the release of Home: Voices of Connecticut’s Foster Youth, with a book event at Metro Bis Restaurant in Simsbury, CT.

Youth in state care – whether involved in the state’s child welfare or juvenile justice systems – are some of Connecticut’s most vulnerable and most courageous young people. There are too few opportunities for these young people to share their stories with the broader public, including the policymakers who make the decisions that influence their lives. Connecticut Voices for Children is committed to sharing the voices of youth in state care and training youth to effectively advocate for themselves. In accordance with that aim, we worked with young people across the state to compile and publish a short book of their writings—essays, poems, stories, and other pieces—focused on their experiences in state care.
This book, authored by youth and alumni of the foster care system, arose from a longtime partnership between CT Voices and the Department of Children and Families (DCF). Through this partnership, we aim to provide ongoing, empowering advocacy experiences for youth in state care. We work with DCF’s Youth Advisory Boards (YABs) to prepare youth leaders to express their concerns directly to policymakers through public speaking and testimony. We lead workshops to train youth around the state in strategic sharing, writing legislative testimony, and other skills essential to self-advocacy. In short, we recognize that youth in care can be their own best advocates, and work to enable them to do so.
This project represents a slight, creative departure from our usual work. A year and a half ago, while working with YAB members across the state on Connecticut’s first-ever Foster Care Bill of Rights and Expectations, we recognized that, for some youth, direct written or spoken advocacy was not a comfortable, safe way to explore their experiences in state care. Some youth needed a more creative outlet for self-expression and self-advocacy, and few existed in our state. This youth writing project is an initial attempt to create a meaningful alternative mode of self-expression and self-advocacy for youth in foster care.

The project began as collaboration between Connecticut Voices for Children, organizers from the New Haven People’s Arts Collective (PAC), and the YABs. Our project sought to bring high-quality creative writing programming to DCF-involved adolescents. Through such programming, youth can access safe opportunities for healthy, positive self-image and community building.  We brought in PAC to facilitate a series of dynamic creative writing workshops across the state, and solicited writings from youth and alumni through the staff coordinators of the YABs. The response was overwhelmingly positive: youth continued trying to submit new pieces of writing long after our listed deadline passed.
Connecticut Voices for Children would like to thank all of the incredible authors whose pieces are featured in Home: Anthony Marrero, April Posey, Ashley Chevrette, Brian Gibbons, Chris Highsmith, Crystal Astrachan, Dan Clark, Eddie Rosa Serrano, Eric Beering, Faith Hatheway, Jaquan Harris, Jessyca Magnuson, Kiara Reyes, Lindsay Novak, Mike D., Monica Figueroa, Nicholas Obertz, Quanitra McCray, Ronaele Williams, Tabby Gable, and William Normandin. In addition, we would like to offer a special thanks to Lexie Pérez-Grüber of First Focus, herself an alumna of Connecticut’s DCF system, for writing the foreword to the book.

Connecticut Voices for Children would also like to thank DCF Commissioner Joette Katz, the America’s Promise Alliance, the Bronfman Alumni Venture Fund, Sonia Shannon, and Christopher Prosperi and Courtney Febbroriello of Metro Bis for their generous support.

Our book release event last week was a celebration of all of our authors. We invited DCF Commissioner Joette Katz to share remarks, and welcomed Lexie Pérez-Grüber to address our young authors. Many of the authors read their pieces aloud, some for the first time ever. It was an empowering, moving event. Commissioner Katz departed from her prepared remarks, declaring herself “overwhelmed.” At the end of the program, the authors had an opportunity to sign their books for the attendees. A highlight was a moment when one author, April Posey, spontaneously broke into song, and all the attendees grew silent, letting her voice fill the room.

The full text of the book is available online. To request a printed copy of the book, please reach out to Nicole Updegrove at nupdegrove@ctvdrupal.asqhost.com. For physical copies, we ask for a suggested donation of $10.00 to cover printing costs. All donations are tax-deductible.

CCJEF vs. Rell: Preschool is one path to equity but not on its own

Whether the state has an obligation to support preschool is at the center of a recent development in the CCJEF vs. Rell case. CCJEF, the Connecticut Coalition for Justice in Education Funding, is a group of municipal leaders, educators, advocates, parents and children who filed suit against the state’s education funding system in 2005 claiming that the state has not met its constitutional obligation to provide an adequate and equitable public education to all students. Since the time of the original filing, the State Superior Court issued a pretrial ruling in 2010 that the state is must provide an adequate standard of quality for public education for all children. As the trial date loomed, in September 2015, the state filed a motion in the case to exclude preschool as a potential remedy in the final decision of the case, claiming that the state constitution does not specifically include preschool as part of a public education. In a victory for CCJEF, in October 2015 the State Superior Court denied the state’s motion, stating that a “high quality preschool is an essential component of suitable educational opportunity.”

This ruling represents an important shift in the way we think about preschool as a necessary component of a public education. As the CCJEF case progresses, the state may consider the creation of a “universal” preschool system as one potential remedy for public school inequity. There is already widespread agreement that we must invest early in children’s lives, especially low-income children and children of color. However, early education advocates recognize that in order for preschool to be effective, it must be of high-quality. This means it must adhere to universal early learning standards, have low teacher-student ratios, and employ highly-qualified educators (who are offered competitive compensation so that they can be attracted to and retained in the field). Early education advocates have also emphasized that the state must fund preschool at a rate that will support all of the above. Access to high-quality preschool experiences is but one strategy among several to reduce our state’s persistent achievement gap and reduce inequities between low income students and students of color and their affluent, white peers.

While access to high-quality preschool programs remains vital to combat the achievement gap, as a state we must ensure that gains achieved in early education are sustainable in a high-quality K-12 system for all public school students. And though equitable investments in preschool and K-12 schooling are necessary, improving life opportunities in communities across the state requires an affirmative investment in the systems and programs that impact the day to day lives of Connecticut’s citizens. Specifically, we must invest in equitable opportunity for all citizens in housing, health, and higher education to impact educational experiences. Investments in early childhood experiences are only sustainable if we consider the ways that education, housing, health and higher education are connected to support children on their journey from childhood to adulthood.

Equity must begin early. The inequities in life opportunity begin long before children cross the threshold of their local public school. While preschool alone is not the panacea for deep race inequities in education and life outcomes, preschool provides one opportunity to ready children for future education. The state superior court argued that preschool is “essential” to “sustainable” life opportunities in its ruling. As arguments in the CCJEF vs. Rell case progress, we encourage advocates, stakeholders and citizens to stay focused on the importance of early education as a crucial driver of equitable access to opportunities for all of our state’s children.

10 Charts that Explain Connecticut’s Economic Recovery

Connecticut’s recovery from the Great Recession has created winners and losers, with significant disparities that can be tracked by geography, race, industry and age. The charts below provide the top line news culled from our 2015 State of Working Connecticut report (some charts are updated to reflect newly available data).

For more on these trends, read the full report here and RSVP to our 15th Annual Budget Forum, where we’ll take a deeper dive on the recovery’s effect on these disparities.

1. Total Number of Jobs in Connecticut Fewer Than Before the Great Recession.
While the total number of jobs in the United States rebounded to pre-recession levels over 18 months ago, Connecticut continues to fall short, with nearly 20,000 fewer jobs in September 2015 than in December 2007. Since the state recently recovered all of the private sector jobs lost in the recession, this difference results from lower public sector employment levels.

2. And Those Jobs That Are Coming Back are Concentrated in Low-Wage Industries
Of the state’s eight largest industries, only three have the same number of jobs, or more, than they had when the recession began – professional services, health care & social assistance, and accommodation & food services.

3. Unemployment Declines Mirror Region and Nation
In September 2015, unemployment in Connecticut and the average unemployment rate in neighboring states was 5.2%, higher than the national rate of 5.1%, and just above pre-Recession levels, when it fell below 5%. But that’s not the full story; nearly 40% of the unemployed have been unemployed for over six months – a higher share than in previous downturns and ninth highest in the nation.
 

4. But, Unemployment Varies Widely by Place
For example the rate is significantly higher in the cities of New Haven, Waterbury, Bridgeport, and Hartford than in the state as a whole.

5. …and  Unemployment Varies Widely by Race
Before the recession, the unemployment rate for black and Hispanic workers exceeded that of white residents by nearly five percentage points. But that gap’s grown during the recovery: for example, unemployment for black residents (13.1%) is now more than double the rate for white residents (5.1%).

6. As Low-Wage Industries Dominate Recovery, Wages Continue to Decline
Not unlike the national recovery, wage growth in Connecticut has stagnated or tumbled (a challenge for workers and state budgets alike). Since 2009, Connecticut’s median wage dropped $2.50, or 11.1%, compared to a 5.3 % drop in neighboring states and a 4.0 % drop nationally.

7. …Even Though Nutmeggers Work Harder than Before
While state productivity grew by 111.3% from 1979 to 2013, the median hourly wage increased just 22.7% over that time. Had Connecticut’s wage growth kept pace with productivity, the average worker would enjoy a median hourly wage of $35.24 in 2013.
 

8. Workers of Color and Ethnicity Experience Enormous Wage Gaps
When the recovery began in 2009, white workers made 40% more than Hispanic workers and 38% more than black workers. Six years later, white workers make 59% more than Hispanic workers and 37% more than black workers. Assuming full-time year-round work, that’s $16,764 less per year for Hispanic workers and $15,100 less for black workers – the equivalent of the annual cost of high-quality childcare. 
 

9.  Gap Widens Between the Highest and Lowest Earners
Between 1979 and 2014, wages for workers at the top 10% soared by 45% while workers at the bottom 10 percent saw their inflation adjusted wages fall by $0.26 per hour.
 

10. Health of Labor Force is Cause for Optimism Looking Forward
The prime age employment-to-population ratio measures the portion of workers from ages 25 to 54 who are employed. Following a recession-led decline, recent data show a sharp uptick – a positive sign when assessing economic recovery.

Fortunately, Connecticut is well equipped to tackle the challenges described here. As the state’s economy begins to pick up steam, ensuring shared prosperity requires state investment in human capital, such as high-quality education for all children and youth, from cradle to career, stronger tax credits for low-income working families and families with dependents, and property tax reform to address geographic resource disparities that threaten school quality and other local services.

The Family First Act Offers Hope to Reduce Child Neglect & Abuse

It’s no surprise that children do best when they have strong stable families.  But when children are at risk because of family dysfunction, our nation’s approach has long been to protect the child by removal rather than remediation.  Our federal financing reflects that: Title IV-E, the single largest federal funding stream for child welfare-involved youth, reimburses states for costs associated with placing children in out-of-home care, but cannot be drawn down for costs associated with strengthening families.

New proposed federal legislation, which will be introduced by the Finance Committee late next week, seeks to change that. The Family First Act would expand the permissible use of IV-E dollars to include services for families on the brink of entering the child welfare system.  In other words, federal funds could support state intervention at the front end, as well as the back. The idea behind it is simple: if we can prevent families from reaching the point where the state needs to intervene for the well-being of the child, everyone benefits: the state (from the long-term cost savings and efficiencies achieved), the family, and, most importantly, the child.

The bill builds off two bills introduced earlier this year: The Family Stability and Kinship Act, sponsored by Oregon Senator Ron Wyden, and the All Kids Matter Act, sponsored by Colorado Senator Michael Bennett and Idaho Senator Michael Crapo. “What this is all about is creating as many good choices as we possibly can for youngsters to grow up in  a safe, healthy environment. That means keeping families together,” Wyden said of his bill back in August.  Bennett’s words, in September, reinforced this: “Under the current system, we’re tying the hands of child welfare advocates in many states and only allowing them to help after a kid experiences abuse or neglect. [All Kids Matter] gives states more flexibility to prevent and intervene before the worst happens.”

Specifically, the Family First Act would allow IV-E funds to be used in the following ways for the families of children “at imminent risk” of being placed into foster care:

  • for children at home, costs associated with evidence-based mental health and substance abuse services, in-home parent training, and family counseling, for up to 12 months
  • for children in kinship care, costs associated with all of the above, as well as short-term financial support designed to pay for concrete goods and services that will facilitate kinship placement (such as transportation, clothing, rent and utility assistance, etc.)

Importantly, families do not have to meet any income-eligibility guidelines in order for states to be able to draw down dollars for these services (in contrast to IV-E guidelines for out-of-home cost reimbursement, which do have income-eligibility limits). This opens up these services to all families who may need them, not just the very poorest.

Though short-term financial assistance for children at home is not reimbursable via IV-E dollars under this proposal, the bill does create a capped mandatory funding allotment for short-term (three months) crisis assistance to these families under Title IV-B, a separate, non-entitlement, federal funding stream that supports the Promoting Safe and Stable Families Program. Making this funding mandatory, rather than discretionary, as it is now, guarantees it will be there to support families, and will not be subject to political maneuvering.

The Family First Act has another significant component as well: incentivizing the use of family foster care over congregate care. It limits the situations in which IV-E dollars can be used to compensate states for the cost of congregate care to those in which residentially treatment is clinically mandated, and heightens accountability around this determination.  With this provision, as in those that seek to expand the use of preventative services, the Act recognizes that all children deserve to live with families, and are most likely to succeed when they do.

The bill’s passage is far from assured. Although it is likely to have bi-partisan support, it will also have a high fiscal note. But this is the kind of investment that makes sense. We believe that paying now means savings later – savings from fewer out-of-home placements, savings from less need down the line.

Over the last five years, Connecticut has already started moving in the direction of putting family first: reducing congregate care, expanding kinship care, and implementing Family Assessment Response, a program that connects low-to-moderate risk families to supports and services within their community. The federal government is finally catching on to what we in Connecticut already knew: we should support children in their families and communities and we shouldn’t wait to support them until we can’t wait any longer. The Family First Act would enable Connecticut to continue and expand this important work, and we will follow and report on its progress in the weeks and months to come.